Choose the right place for you


  • Wi-Fi
  • Non Smoking Only
  • Pets Allowed


  • 9+ Exceptional
  • 8+ Fabulous
  • 7+ Very Good

Vacation rental deals in Long Island

We have selected the best vacation rentals in Long Island. Save money with Bluepillow by comparing the best deals from major travel websites in Long Island

  • Sun Living: Entire Loft! 4 Bedrooms, 2.5 Bath

    10 Exceptional (9)
    • 7 Guests · 4Bedrooms
    Upstairs loft unit with private access, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, small balcony and outdoor grill with seating area, kitchenette with fridge, hotplate, microwave and dining area. Unit has all the basic amenities,
  • The Blue Cottage

    10 Exceptional (5)
    • 4 Guests · 2Bedrooms
    The Blue Cottage is a cozy 2 bedroom 1 bathroom house located on a Family Estate in the quaint island settlement/town of Hamiltons on the beautiful island of Long Island in the exotic Bahamas. The cottage
  • Tiny's Hurricane Hole - Key Lime Cottage

    10 Exceptional (48)
    • 2 Guests · 0Bedroom
    Cute Little Beach Club on Quaint Family Island. KEY LIME - COTTAGE = TOES IN THE SAND VACATION. Close to restaurants and services. You’ll love this place because of the coziness, the location, and
  • Home living by the Ocean - Fox 2

    10 Exceptional (7)
    • 5 Guests · 2Bedrooms
    Fox-2 is newly re-built home, located in the elevated development of Stella Maris, Long Island Newly renovated, it has a fresh, clean open air concept. It lends itself to modern life-style, Bahamian
  • wilk cay efficiency oceanside

    10 Exceptional (3)
    • 3 Guests · 1Bedroom
    Long Island Bahamas is a beautiful, quiet island with many miles of secluded beaches. Perfect for relaxing, hiking, fishing (Bone fishing) and beach combing. It contains many attractions such as the Dean’s
  • Country Cove Inn

    9.8 Exceptional (5)
    • Hotel
    Situated in Lower Deadmanʼs Cay, Country Cove Inn features free WiFi throughout the property. Every room is equipped with a flat-screen TV with satellite channels. At the inn, each room has a wardrobe.

The best places to stay in Long Island

Book an apartment in Long Island and choose the right accommodation for your needs

  • Little Island Room

    • 2 Guests · 1Bedroom
    Room has private entrance from outside. Building is about 30 feet off of Queen's Highway. Very clean and quite. Back is less than 200 feet from Caribbean Sea. Small convenience store and 2 restaurant within
  • Beautiful Oceanside 1,2 or 3 bedroom House on Secluded Protected Cove

    9.6 Exceptional (11)
    • 10 Guests · 3Bedrooms
    This colorful artisan Bahamian style house with wrap-around porch is on a private sandy beach. The beach is in a unique protected cove, perfect for kids. Enjoy miles of uninterrupted secluded beaches,
  • Moonshine House

    • 4 Guests · 2Bedrooms
    Moonshine House is the perfect getaway for anyone looking to enjoy downtime. Its a three bedroom that is located in central Long Island but is not far away from Slat Pond that have grocery stores, gas
  • King Room Retreat at the Creek

    • 2 Guests · 1Bedroom
    Greenwich Creek Lodge has four king rooms with ensuite bathrooms. Each room has ductless aircondtion and ceiling fans with tiled floors. There is a microwave, refrigerator, electic kettle and a flatscreenTV.
  • Bayview Seashells

    • 2 Guests · 1Bedroom
    Bayview Seashells is centrally. We are only a ten minute drive south of the Deadman's Cay Airport. Bayview Seashells is just a walking distance to food store, liquor store, a fish house where you can get
  • Maria's Rentals, Stella Maris, L.I., Bahamas

    • 4 Guests · 2Bedrooms
    Welcome to Maria's Rentals! Our spacious one bedroom rental unit is inviting and fully equipped with a ductless unit in rooms. Each queen bed sleeps two. Kitchen has full sized refrigerator, microwave

Farmhouse or Hotel? Choose from the best offers

Choose the accommodation tailor-made for you for your next vacation: sleep in a farmhouse or sleep in a hotel?

  • Farmstays in Long Island
    Farmstays in Long Island
  • Hotels in Long Island
    Hotels in Long Island

Top destinations in Long Island